
Photo by Pisit Heng
Picture it.
You’re a Gentile living near Jerusalem in AD 45.
You’ve been hearing stories about a man named Jesus. They say He healed the sick, gave sight to the blind, forgave sins, and even raised the dead.
And then you hear the most unbelievable story of all.
He was crucified by the Romans. He was buried. And He came back to life.
Wait. What?
Does that mean He defeated death? Does it mean He somehow won against Rome? Could this really be the Messiah everyone has been waiting for?
It’s almost too incredible to believe.
But everyone keeps talking about Him, and you want to know more.
Eventually, you get the opportunity to meet some of His disciples & they tell you about Jesus, His teachings, His death, and His resurrection, and that forgiveness and reconciliation with God are available through Him.
Week after week, you begin meeting with other believers. They welcome you, teach you, and share their lives with you. For the first time, you feel as though you’ve found something worth giving your life to.
You’ve found the Messiah.
But then, other teachers arrive.
They call themselves followers of Christ, too. They know the Scriptures. They understand the covenant God made with Israel. And they have some important things to tell you.
They explain that if you really want to belong to God’s people, there’s something else you need to do.
You need to be circumcised.
You need to keep the Law of Moses, observe the Sabbaths, follow the dietary restrictions, celebrate the feasts, and learn the requirements for ritual purity.
After all, can you truly be part of God’s covenant people if you haven’t taken on the covenant sign given to Abraham? How can you fully participate in Israel’s religious life if you haven’t done what God commanded?
And what about the Temple? Surely that’s where you need to go to draw near to God, offer sacrifices, and celebrate the feasts.
You’ve heard about the new covenant, but these teachers make you wonder whether you’ve misunderstood what it means.
Is faith in Jesus really enough? Or is there more you need to do?
You don’t want to disobey God. You don’t want to take His commandments lightly. You certainly don’t want to discover years from now that you were wrong about what He requires.
These teachers seem knowledgeable. They can point to the scriptures. Their arguments sound convincing, and you don’t want to risk being disobedient to God.
You want to follow the Messiah. You want to be obedient. You want to honor God with your entire life.
So you agree.
You undergo circumcision.
You begin observing the commandments as they’ve taught you. You organize your life around the Sabbath, the dietary restrictions, and the biblical feasts. You learn about ritual purity and the importance of the Temple.
You attend synagogue regularly, even though the teachings you originally embraced about Jesus aren’t necessarily what you hear there.
You make sacrifices because you believe this is what faithfulness requires.
And you do it all because you love God.
Years pass.
Your new way of life becomes second nature. You study the Scriptures. You learn the traditions. You try to understand every commandment and how it applies to your life.
You want to get everything right.
After all, you don’t want to be someone who claims to follow God but refuses to obey Him.
Perhaps you’ve sacrificed relationships along the way. Perhaps your family doesn’t understand your choices. You’ve given up the life you once knew because you believe you’ve found something far more important.
Twenty-five years pass.
You’ve spent a quarter-century building your life around these teachings.
You’re now in AD 70.
And everything changes.
The Roman armies descend on Jerusalem.
The city is devastated. The Temple is destroyed.
Stop for a moment & imagine what that would mean to you.
The Temple wasn’t just another building. It was the center of Israel’s sacrificial system. The priesthood, the altar, and the sanctuary were integral to carrying out the commandments that depended on Temple worship.
Now the Temple is gone.
You can no longer offer sacrifices there. The priesthood can no longer perform its Temple service as before. The feasts cannot be observed in precisely the same way, and the commandments that depend on the Temple cannot be carried out as they once were.
You can still observe the Sabbath. You can still follow dietary restrictions. You can still celebrate feasts in ways that remain possible.
But you cannot maintain the entire system as it existed before.
And suddenly, you’re faced with a question you never expected to ask.
What happens when you can no longer do everything you’ve been taught is necessary to obey God?
You’ve spent twenty-five years believing that taking on these covenant obligations was essential to following Christ properly.
You’ve believed that circumcision and the Mosaic covenant were part of what it meant to belong fully to God’s people.
But now the Temple is gone.
What does that mean for your relationship with God?
Were you wrong about what He required of you? Did you misunderstand the covenant?
And if you were wrong about something so fundamental, what else might you have misunderstood?
For the first time in 25 years, you begin to wonder if everything you believed was wrong.
You believed you needed to be circumcised. You believed you needed to take on the Mosaic covenant to be fully accepted by God. You spent decades trying to follow every commandment you could.
But now the Temple is gone, and you can’t help asking yourself some terrifying questions.
If I was wrong about what God required of me, was I wrong about everything?
Was Jesus really the Messiah? Was His resurrection real? Was the gospel I first heard even true?
Or did I spend twenty-five years of my life following teachers who convinced me that Christ wasn’t enough on His own?
Think about the tragedy of that possibility.
You came to Christ because you believed He was the answer.
But then someone convinced you that you needed something more.
And now, when the system you were taught to depend on has been shattered, you’re left questioning the very foundation of your faith.
If the people who taught me how to follow God were wrong about what He required, how can I know they were right about Christ?
What do you do when the very people who taught you how to follow God may have led you away from the message you first believed?
What do you have left when the Temple falls?
Christ.
Christ is still there.
His resurrection has not been undone. His promises have not been destroyed. His sacrifice has not lost its power because the Temple in Jerusalem has been reduced to rubble.
The Messiah you first heard about twenty-five years ago is still the Messiah.
But here’s the question that changes everything.
What if you had listened to the apostles instead?
The Conversation That Had Already Happened
Let’s rewind the clock.
It’s around AD 49 or 50. The Temple is still standing. Sacrifices are still being offered in Jerusalem.
And the early church is facing a controversy.
Some believers are teaching that Gentiles must be circumcised according to the custom of Moses to be saved.
Think about that.
This isn’t a modern debate. It isn’t a question that arose centuries after Jesus. It’s happening while the original apostles are still alive and the Temple is still operating.
The controversy is brought before the apostles and elders in Jerusalem, as recorded in Acts 15.
The question is straightforward:
Must Gentiles become circumcised and take on the Law of Moses to belong to God’s people through Christ?
Peter stands up and speaks.
He reminds the assembly that God gave the Holy Spirit to Gentiles, just as He had to Jewish believers. God made no distinction between them, cleansing their hearts by faith.
Then Peter asks why they would place a yoke on the disciples’ necks that neither their ancestors nor they had been able to bear.
Paul and Barnabas then describe the signs and wonders God has performed among the Gentiles.
James responds, and the assembly reaches its decision.
The Gentiles turning to God are not to be burdened with the full set of Mosaic covenant requirements being demanded by those teachers.
The apostles give Gentile believers specific instructions, but they do not require circumcision or impose the entire Law of Moses on them.
Read that again.
The apostles did not tell Gentiles that they had to become Jews before they could follow the Messiah.
They did not make circumcision the gateway to salvation.
They did not tell Gentiles that their faith was incomplete until they adopted Israel’s covenant identity.
They addressed this exact controversy and refused to impose the very requirement that had caused it.
Now imagine our Gentile convert from the beginning of this story.
What if someone had explained Acts 15 to him before he underwent circumcision?
What if he had understood that the apostles had already considered this question?
What if he had known that the leaders of the early church did not require Gentiles to take on the Mosaic covenant to be accepted through Christ?
He could still have studied Israel’s Scriptures. He could still have learned about the biblical feasts, the Sabbath, and the commandments God gave to Israel. He could still have grown in his understanding of the Jewish context of Jesus and the faith he had embraced.
But he wouldn’t have needed to believe that circumcision and taking on the Mosaic covenant were prerequisites for belonging to Christ.
He wouldn’t have needed to build his entire understanding of faithfulness around requirements the apostles had declined to impose on Gentiles.
And when AD 70 arrived, the destruction of the Temple would not have forced him to question whether he had misunderstood the conditions of his salvation.
His hope could remain where it belonged.
In Christ.
What Does This Mean for Us Today?
This thought experiment isn’t about condemning Jewish believers who continued observing the Torah. It isn’t about criticizing someone who chooses to celebrate the biblical feasts, observe the Sabbath, or follow dietary practices. And it isn’t an argument that studying the Torah is pointless.
It’s about the difference between choosing to observe something and being told that you must observe it to be fully accepted by God.
Those are two very different things.
Someone can choose to celebrate the biblical feasts because doing so helps them understand Scripture. Someone else might observe the Sabbath or follow certain dietary practices because they find meaning in them.
Those choices are not the same as teaching that Gentile believers must adopt the Mosaic covenant to be truly obedient to God or to have a complete relationship with Him.
The question isn’t whether these practices can have value.
The question is whether God requires Gentile believers to take on a covenant that the apostles did not impose on them.
And that brings us right back to Acts 15.
Why would we place a burden on Gentile believers that the apostles specifically addressed and declined to require?
Why would we tell people that faith in Christ is insufficient unless they also adopt a particular set of covenant obligations?
Why would we make circumcision, dietary restrictions, or Sabbath observance tests of whether someone is truly following God?
If we believe these things are necessary, we need to ask a serious question.
Where did the apostles teach that Gentiles must take on the Mosaic covenant to be fully accepted by God through Christ?
Not where did the commandments originate.
Not whether they were good for Israel.
Not whether they appear in Scripture.
Where did the apostles require Gentile converts to take them all on?
Because those are different questions, and answering one does not automatically answer the other.
Our hypothetical Gentile spent twenty-five years believing that taking on the Mosaic covenant was necessary to follow Christ properly.
But the apostles had already addressed that question.
The Temple would eventually fall. The sacrificial system would be profoundly disrupted. The Jewish people would face enormous questions about their future.
Yet the gospel did not collapse with the Temple.
Christ did not become insufficient when the altar disappeared.
And Gentiles did not suddenly lose their standing before God because they could no longer participate in a Temple-centered system they had never been required to enter in the first place.
The Temple fell in AD 70.
But the apostles had already made it clear that Gentiles did not have to become Jews to belong to Christ.
So here’s the question I want you to consider:
Are we teaching people to trust in what Christ has done, or are we teaching them that they must take on additional covenant obligations before their faithfulness can truly count?
Because if the apostles didn’t require it of Gentile believers, we should be very careful about requiring it of them today.