The Rise of Works-Based Christian Lifestyle Ministries as a Response to a Decadent Culture

Photo by Isaac Quick on Unsplash

In response to roughly 50 years of cultural decline, many teachers and believers have decided that enough is enough, and it’s time to restructure society. They’re recommending dress codes, lifestyle changes, avoidance of pleasure, avoiding fun, and even saying that empathy is a sin.

The gospel has little to do with any of these ministries.

There are many Christian ministries sprouting up on YouTube and Facebook that are based around various works-based doctrines. Many ministries are not preaching the gospel. Instead are preaching that believers are sanctified by living a stoic lifestyle that avoids pleasure, discipline and encourages strict blandness.

The Bible on Fun and Pleasure

For some people, living a stoic lifestyle may be beneficial, but saying that believers must avoid pleasure is not really biblical. We do see scriptures that criticize pleasure if it is ungodly or put before good works. However, fun, pleasure, and freedom is not bad unless they are used in sinful ways.

Why Teachers Are Preaching Strict Legalism

In modern times, the belief that Christians must live a strict, rigid, rule-based lifestyle is rooted more with the enlightenment’s framing of Christianity than it does with the Bible. They developed this opinion from observing the Puritans, who did not like entertainment, and held strong beliefs about controlling behavior.

There is not anything necessarily wrong with Puritanism in this respect. However, the way that the Puritans lived is not necessarily a facsimile for how the early church lived either and we should always look at the lifestyle of the Puritans as being fit for the time period they lived in.

Historically, college professors, atheists, academics and intellectuals have described Christianity as teaching things like “the body is dirty” or “pleasure is bad”. However, this doesn’t mean that the Bible says this.

As a result, many Christians have begun to believe that the Bible preaches that we should live strict, stoic lifestyles, and have begun to embrace them to spite the academic elites. Even atheist Richard Dawkins was recently quoted into saying that he believed that “cultural Christianity” was good for society (because it keeps order).

While the Bible does teach that we are not to be rebellious and that we should have a specific set of behaviors, these usually rely on two of Christ’s commandments: love the Lord your God, and to Love your neighbor as yourself. What we do with our clothes, how straight we stand, and how tight we have our neckties are our personal preferences, and such ordinances went out with the Old Covenant, which was just for the Jews and the stranger who joined them.

In fact, we should get pleasure from doing the things that the Bible says that is good to do. In Colossians 2:20-22, Paul tells us that the rules of man perish. So why are so many ministries emerging that are telling us that we need to set more strict rules? Wouldn’t it be best to have faith in Christ instead of having to make rules to have others follow them?

In this article, we’re going to show you lists of such rules that are being peddled by these work-based ministries.

1. Teachers and ministries that tell people to avoid activities which can be lawful.

Many ministries claim that we should avoid doing things that are fun or pleasurable. They say that it is being worldly.

What things are we talking about?

  • Watching movies or television
  • Playing or watching sports
  • All entertainment is “bread and circuses”
  • Playing video games
  • Avoiding creative hobbies

However, just because something is fun or that it is something that people commonly do, does not make it worldly.

They become worldly when we do them because everybody else does them when we know they are wrong. For instance, watching adult content, binge drinking, or watching raunchy movies is worldly.

Believers sometimes make exceptions for things if they seem old-world, or traditional. For instance, playing video games is seen as “worldly”, but playing games at the local carnival are seen as family fun.

Christians who avoid so many fun hobbies and activities will often swap them with activities that they believe is okay, like prepping enormous amounts of food, shooting guns at the shooting range, smoking cigars and drinking scotch with the guys, watching conspiracy theory videos on YouTube, and attending “Christian” conferences with unhinged speakers who promote anything but the gospel.

2. Teachers and ministries that mandate strict sexual roles between men and women.

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

The Bible does tell us that men and women are different. However, many add their own doctrine to this fact. Strict identity between male and female is becoming increasingly popular to counter the trend of transgenderism.

These beliefs can place burdensome dress codes on people. Other beliefs can contribute to financial hardships such as forbidding a mother to have a part-time job. The Eastern Orthodox teachers on YouTube often push men to apply extreme stoicism, and that becoming emotionally apathetic will make you more of a man.

Christian Nationalism (think Doug Wilson, Joel Webbon) also heavily promotes extreme sexual rules, such as women being in the kitchen making sandwiches while the men sit and smoke cigars.

These teachings can cause unnecessary contention when mandated as if they were commanded from God.

Here is a list of such teachings:

  • Women are forbidden to work or have a job
  • Married couples must have babies (if able to)
  • Men must get married (not marrying is seen as irresponsibility)
  • Women must not lead in any context
  • Women must be good cooking/making bread/gardening
  • Shaving/not shaving your beard (depends on the ministry)
  • Wearing makeup (women)
  • Wearing modern clothes or jewelry
  • Wearing shorts and sandals (for men)
  • Adult men should not wear caps, hats, jeans, and should wear button-down shirts, and dress pants when in public.
  • Large families are mandatory (Hebrew Roots, Mormonism)
  • Men should always wear suits on Sundays (Independent Fundamentalist Baptist congregations
  • Men must always dress “butch” (this depends on culture)
  • Dying hair or altering appearance to make oneself more attractive
  • Women must wear skirts, dresses, and should never wear pants
  • Women must always have long hair
  • Men should always have very short hair

In addition, some teachers from ministries (Christian Nationalist) teach teachings that view women as lesser beings. However, Proverbs 31 is a passage about a woman who owns a business, sells things at the market, and prepares meals from her garden to provide for her family.

3. Medical/Health/Wellness

The rise of disease has led a lot of people to blame the cause of sickness on everyday choices that we make. However, anybody can get sick. Medical health and dietary beliefs some of these ministries preach:

  • Various ministries are teaching that all vaccines are bad and that it is wrong to take a vaccine to prevent an illness
  • Forbidding the eating of herbs and spices (SDA) because they allegedly arouse the nervous system and can lead to giving into temptations. However, in the Bible we see spices like cumin, bitter herbs, and spiced wine being consumed without any type of stipulation.
  • Getting circumcised (sometimes preached to be a health practice rather than a covenant sign)
  • Wellness practices (like meditation) are occult
  • All medicine or seeing the doctor is “pharmakeia” (they can also believe that holistic wellness can be occult)
  • Adopting a vegan diet (SDA) is the most biblical
  • Avoid alcohol (sometimes this is taught that all references to wine in the Bible was juice)

4. Observance of Days and Feasts

Every day is made by God. So, why do some Christians seem to believe that they should avoid doing things on particular days?

8Formerly, when you did not know God, you were slaves to those who by nature are not gods. 9But now that you know God, or rather are known by God, how is it that you are turning back to those weak and worthless principles? Do you wish to be enslaved by them all over again? 10You are observing special days and months and seasons and years! 11I fear for you, that my efforts for you may have been in vain. 12I beg you, brothers, become like me, for I became like you. You have done me no wrong.

Galations 1:8-12

  • You can’t provide for your family on the Sabbath (Hebrew Roots)
  • You have to replace the Gregorian calendar (Hebrew Roots)
  • You have to start the day at sundown (Hebrew Roots)
  • Sunday church is honoring “the venerable day of the sun” (SDA, Hebrew Roots)
  • Not taking care of emergencies on the Sabbath or Feast Days (Hebrew Roots)
  • Don’t celebrate so-called “pagan holidays”
  • Don’t tell people “Merry Christmas”

5. Avoiding Traditions and Practices That Have Some Ties With Paganism

  • All pagan customs are occult (although some of them are)
  • Eliminate all cultural practices
  • Be ashamed of your ethnic or national background
  • All people must wear tassels (Hebrew Roots)

6. Forbidden Lifestyle Practices/Political Beliefs

  • Embrace communal living (yet reject socialism and social welfare)
  • Not making enough money is bad (prosperity gospel)
  • Not having money in the bank because the “banks are part of the Beast System”
  • General distrust of authority figures even if they bare good fruit
  • Avoid secular education (homeschooling children)
  • Reject modern education and embrace Greek philosophy (Eastern Orthodox and Christian Nationalism)
  • Don’t question the teachers
  • Liberalism is evil, and capitalism is biblical
  • Accepting government welfare, charity, foodstamps and stamping out universal healthcare is evil and encourages people to be sluggards

6. Making Excuses to Treat People Badly/Showing Partiality/”Sin of Empathy”

Christ tells us that you will do well to take care of people. This is very clear on the sermon on the mount.

However, some teachers are preaching to ignore Christ’s teachings in favor of adopting strict and rigid lifestyles. This means being harsh to people because they are struggling in life, in order to be an example to them. However, this is not condoned in the Bible.

The book of James is clear that believers must avoid showing partiality to people in the way that the world does. This means that we shouldn’t give people the front seat just because they have high rank in the world, like showing partiality to a rich person or a military man in uniform over an elderly or poor person. That is the way the world values people, and not the way believers should.

The Gospel Matters

Now, some of these things are necessarily good or bad. Other ones are anti-Christian and promote hypocritical behavior.

For instance, if something is a stumbling block to you, it is best to avoid those stumbling blocks even if they are lawful, because not all of those things are necessarily beneficial.

For instance, if watching sports causes you to drink a lot of alcohol to the point of being drunk, then it may be a good idea to not watch them. If you come from a family that has practiced occult things, and you believe that a custom reminds you of these occult practices, then avoid them.

However, other teachings are more dangerous. Teachings that tell us to shun the homeless or not to eat with sinners are not biblical.

Faith that comes by force or through social pressure is not true belief.

While we all have political beliefs on what we believe is the ideal society, we have to remember that any change–even if it’s good–is temporary and that at the end of the day, what matters is preaching the gospel.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top